To make a payment on your insurance policy, please send a check to your insurance company directly using the address displayed below. If there is not an address listed for your company, please contact us directly.
To see more information about a company, click on its name. Some of the companies we represent accept payments online. Use the link in the Online Payments column below to go to your company's online payment center.
| Company | Address | Phone | Online Payments |
|---|---|---|---|
| Personal | |||
| Agency Insurance Company | 800-492-5629 | ||
| Allstate | 800-901-1732 | www.allstate.com | |
| Brethren Mutual Insurance Company | 800-621-4264 | ||
| Cincinnati | PO Box 145496 Cincinnati, OH 45250 | 513-870-2000 | www.cinfin.com |
| Cumberland | 800-232-6992 | cumberlandagencylink.com | |
| Encompass Insurance | P.O. Box 660679 Dallas, TX 75266 | 866-430-2916 | www.encompassinsurance.com |
| Frederick Mutual | 800-544-8737 | www.fredmut.com | |
| GMAC | 877-468-3466 | www.secureinsforms.com | |
| Main Street America Group | The Main Street America Group P.O. Box 2004 Keene, N.H. 03431 | 800-611-0958 | payments.billmatrix.com |
| Montgomery Insurance | P.O. Box 2051 Keene, NH 03431-7051 | 877-675-4411 | www.montgomery-ins.com |
| Progressive | P.O. Box 4640 Carol Stream, IL 60197-9601 | 800-888-7764 | www.progressiveagent.com |
| Safeco | P.O. Box 6476 Carol Stream, IL 60197-6476 | 800-332-3226 | customer.safeco.com |
| Selective | Selective Insurance Company of America Box 371468 Pittsburgh, PA 15250-7468 | 888-974-7400 | customer1.selectiveinsurance.com |
| State Auto | P.O. Box 182738 Columbus OH 43218-2738 | 800-444-9950 | www.stateauto.com |
| The Hartford | P.O. Box 2917 Hartford, CT 06192 | 800-624-5578 | service.thehartford.com |
| Travelers | One Tower Square Hartford, CT 06183-1001 | 877-878-2468 | mytravelers.com |
| Windsor Mount Joy Mutual | 800-233-0228 | ||
| Commercial | |||
| Allstate | 800-901-1732 | www.allstate.com | |
| Brethren Mutual Insurance Company | 800-621-4264 | ||
| Cincinnati | PO Box 145496 Cincinnati, OH 45250 | 513-870-2000 | www.cinfin.com |
| Cumberland | 800-232-6992 | cumberlandagencylink.com | |
| Frederick Mutual | 800-544-8737 | www.fredmut.com | |
| Main Street America Group | The Main Street America Group P.O. Box 2004 Keene, N.H. 03431 | 800-611-0958 | payments.billmatrix.com |
| Montgomery Insurance | P.O. Box 2051 Keene, NH 03431-7051 | 877-675-4411 | www.montgomery-ins.com |
| Selective | Selective Insurance Company of America Box 371468 Pittsburgh, PA 15250-7468 | 888-974-7400 | customer1.selectiveinsurance.com |
| State Auto | P.O. Box 182738 Columbus OH 43218-2738 | 800-444-9950 | www.stateauto.com |
| The Hartford | P.O. Box 2917 Hartford, CT 06192 | 800-624-5578 | service.thehartford.com |
| Life & Health | |||
| Allstate | 800-901-1732 | www.allstate.com | |
| Anthem | 888-641-5224 | www.anthem.com | |
| Carefirst | webapp.carefirst.com | ||
800-331-9471
9:00 AM - 5:00 PM, M - F
onancock [at] associatedinsurance [dot] net
Your current insurance may not cover you fully in the event of a catastrophic loss. Learn more.